Purpose: The objective of this study was to compare a synthetic hydrogen peroxide-based chemical proven to be effective in drain sanitizing to naturally derived chitosan-arginine or heat to prevent attachment of or destroy existing L. monocytogenes on the inner surface of model floor drains.
Methods: L. monocytogenes was introduced to result in about 109 planktonic and attached cells within untreated PVC model drain pipes. Treatments (0.13% peroxide based sanitizer, 0.1% chitosan-arginine or 15s of hot water at 95 - 100°C) were applied immediately after inoculation, or after 24h incubation. Following treatment, all pipes were incubated for an additional 24h; planktonic and attached cells were enumerated by plate count.
Results: All treatments significantly (P < 0.05) lowered numbers of planktonic and attached cells recovered. Chitosan-arginine resulted in a 6 log reduction when applied prior to incubation and a 3 log reduction after the inoculum had a chance to grow. Both heat and peroxide significantly outperformed chitosan-arginine (8 to 9 log reduction) and were equally effective before and after incubation. Heat was the only treatment which eliminated planktonic L. monocytogenes.
Significance: Based on these data, a processor can choose between a natural solution, a chemical solution or a physical treatment to combat drain contamination. Applied at the most efficacious time, any of these techniques may lessen the potential for L. monocytogenes to remain as a long term resident in processing plant floor drains.